Boulder Firefighter Collective Bargaining Charter Amendment
Government structureCharter amendment on collective bargaining for firefighters
Guarantees collective bargaining for full-time fire employees in Boulder’s charter, with factfinding and, if necessary, a citywide vote at impasse.
City of Boulder
Kim's Recommendation
NO
Vote No on City of Boulder ballot question 2L
Under Section 73, a firefighter contract outranks any city rule, policy or ordinance that applies only to city employees. Because the section sits in the charter, the council cannot change that by ordinance. The section also opens minimum staffing to bargaining, as an exception to the budget decisions it reserves to management.
If either side rejects the fact finder's recommendations, voters get only the two final offers, with no way to turn down both. Authority over firefighter pay and staffing belongs with elected officials who answer to voters for city spending, not in a charter section or contracts that prevail over the city's employee rules. I oppose writing that arrangement into the charter.
I recommend a no vote on City of Boulder ballot question 2L.
Kim Monson
Host, The Kim Monson Show · President, Colorado Union of Taxpayers · Colorado Voter's Guide 2026
Certified ballot question
Bargaining Rights Union Firefighters in City Charter
Shall the City amend its charter by the addition of a new Sec. 73, "Collective Bargaining for Firefighters," as described in Ordinance 8761 which provides a charter guaranteed right for full-time fire department employees to bargain collectively over matters related to safety, wages, benefits, and all other terms and conditions employment, except those certain terms that are reserved to rights of management as defined in the proposed charter amendment, with impasse to be resolved through non-binding factfinding followed, if necessary, by a vote of the qualified electors of the City?
A yes vote means
Approves the new charter Section 73, guaranteeing collective bargaining over safety, wages, benefits and other terms of employment except those reserved to management.
A no vote means
Rejects adding this collective bargaining guarantee and impasse procedure to the charter.
A Charter Right for Firefighters01
Ordinance 8761, which the City Council adopted on August 6, 2026, asks voters to add Section 73 to the city's Home Rule Charter. Section 73 gives full-time firefighters, up through the rank of battalion chief, the right to bargain collectively with the city, and it recognizes International Association of Firefighters Local 900 as their exclusive representative. The city's ballot page says these rights "currently exist in contract, and the right to take disagreements to impasse is currently in a city ordinance." The city and the union wrote this version together after the union petitioned in April for a broader amendment. The union withdrew the petition on July 24.
Bargaining covers safety, compensation, benefits, promotions, hours, leave, grievance procedures, discipline appeals and all other terms of employment not reserved to management. Firefighters may not strike.
Decisions Left to Management02
Section 73 reserves to the city decisions on hiring, training, layoffs, discipline, technology, work locations and "the Department’s budget, organization, and the merits, necessity and level of any activity or service provided by the city." The city may bargain over those subjects but need not, and they do not go to fact-finding or a vote. The city must still bargain over shift scheduling and over the procedures it uses for promotions, layoffs and discipline. Reserving budget decisions to the city does not bar bargaining over minimum staffing. When a collective bargaining agreement conflicts with a city rule, policy or ordinance that applies only to city employees, the agreement prevails. Any multi-year agreement must carry a non-appropriations clause to comply with TABOR, the Taxpayer's Bill of Rights in the Colorado Constitution.
How an Impasse Is Resolved03
Either side may declare an impasse any time after 45 days from the first bargaining session. The two sides then choose an advisory fact finder by agreement or from a list the American Arbitration Association or a similar organization supplies. The fact finder holds a hearing and recommends either the city's final offer or the union's on each issue. If either side rejects any of the recommendations, the two final offers on every unresolved issue go to Boulder's voters at a special election. Voters must choose one of the two, and the offer that wins a majority binds both parties. The side that rejects the recommendations pays for that election; if both reject them, they split the cost. If unrelated issues also appear on the same special-election ballot, the union pays only its proportionate share of election expenses. Section 73 sets aside, for these elections, the state law requiring at least 90 days between a special election and a regular municipal election.
Effective Date and Cost04
The city's fiscal note reports "no direct fiscal impact of this charter change." If voters approve, Section 73 takes effect January 1, 2027, and supersedes any existing ordinances, policies or procedures on firefighter bargaining. The present agreement with Local 900 stays in force until it expires December 31, 2027. Once the right is in the charter, only another charter amendment that voters approve can change it.
The July 23, 2026 Boulder City Council special meeting agenda packet includes proposed Ordinance 8761 on first reading, with the full text of the proposed charter Sec. 73 and the ballot title for the firefighter collective bargaining charter amendment (the question the guide lists as 2L).