The 2026 election is over (November 3). Official results are on the Colorado Secretary of State’s website.
Kim MonsonKim Monson · Colorado Voter's Guide 2026
Jeremy Chaffin
Retention question

Jeremy Chaffin

Took office on the Twenty-First Judicial District Court in December 2022. The Twenty-First Judicial District Commission on Judicial Performance voted 7 to 0 that he meets performance standards.

Court
Twenty-First Judicial District - District Court
On the ballot in
Mesa County
Term
6 years
Took office
December 2022
Appointed by Gov. Jared Polis, 2022
Appointing governor's party: Democrat
The commission's findingMeets Performance Standardsby a vote of 7 to 0
A yes vote means

Judge Chaffin stays on the Twenty-First Judicial District Court for a new six-year term.

A no vote means

Judge Chaffin leaves the Twenty-First Judicial District Court at the end of his current term.

State and Federal Prosecutor01

Jeremy Chaffin took office on the Twenty-First Judicial District Court in December 2022. He earned a psychology degree from the University of Idaho in 2005 and a law degree from the University of Colorado School of Law in 2011.

He worked as a special assistant attorney general in the consumer protection section of the Colorado Attorney General's Office, then clerked for Judge Nancy Lichtenstein at the Colorado Court of Appeals. In 2014 he moved to Grand Junction and prosecuted cases for the Twenty-First Judicial District until 2017. Before joining the bench he was an assistant United States attorney for the District of Colorado, prosecuting federal crimes throughout western Colorado.

The District Commission's Review02

The Twenty-First Judicial District Commission on Judicial Performance voted 7 to 0 that he meets performance standards, with one commissioner absent, one vacancy and one recusal. The commission reports that 100 percent of attorneys responding to its survey found he meets the standards and that "non-attorney responses were more mixed".

The commission writes that Judge Chaffin "demonstrates excellent legal knowledge and applies the law appropriately in the cases before him" and "is consistently well prepared, and issues prompt well-reasoned rulings grounded in law and fact." It finds "a judicial temperament that is fair, respectful, compassionate, and professional" and writes that he "treats parties, attorneys, litigants, and court staff with dignity, values their time, and actively works to solve problems humanely and creatively."

Career03
2005
Received an undergraduate degree in psychology from the University of Idaho
2011
Earned a law degree from the University of Colorado School of Law
2014 to 2017
Prosecutor with the Twenty-First Judicial District in Grand Junction
December 2022
Took office on the Twenty-First Judicial District Court
Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation, 2026 evaluation
Commission evaluation04
On integrity

“Judge Chaffin’s hard work and integrity are noted by both prosecutors and defense attorneys.”

On courtroom management

“The Commission has directly observed Judge Chaffin’s noteworthy dedication to the legal profession, ability to manage complex matters effectively while maintaining appropriate control over the courtroom proceedings, and timely issuance of orders moving cases forward in a timely and orderly manner.”

On overall

“Based on the totality of the information reviewed, the Commission determined that Judge Chaffin is an asset to the Mesa County Judicial system and consistently demonstrates the competencies required of a judicial officer.”

Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation, 2026 evaluation
The figures05
Commission vote
7 meet · 0 do not meet · 1 absent · 1 vacant
Attorneys surveyed
14 responses · 100% meets standards · 0% does not
Non-attorneys surveyed
16 responses · 57% meets standards · 43% does not
Last retention election
First retention election
Sources06

The 2026 election is over. Requests for personalized guides closed on November 3, 2026. The full guide remains available to read.

Read the full guide