The 2026 election is over (November 3). Official results are on the Colorado Secretary of State’s website.
Kim MonsonKim Monson · Colorado Voter's Guide 2026
OF
Retention question

Olympia Z. Fay

Appointed to the Denver County Court in January 2015. The Denver County Court Commission on Judicial Performance voted 5 to 0 that she meets performance standards.

Court
Second Judicial District - Denver County Court
On the ballot in
Denver County
Term
4 years
Judicial appointment
January 2015
Appointed by Mayor Michael Hancock, 2015
Appointing mayor's party: Democrat
The commission's findingMeets Performance Standardsby a vote of 5 to 0
A yes vote means

Judge Fay stays on the Denver County Court for a new four-year term.

A no vote means

Judge Fay leaves the Denver County Court at the end of her current term.

Appointed to the Denver County Court01

Olympia Z. Fay was appointed to the Denver County Court in January 2015. Voters retained her in 2022 with 79.53 percent of the votes cast on the question: 154,209 yes and 39,683 no.

She began her legal career in private practice as a civil litigator, handling complex commercial, securities and intellectual property cases. Before her appointment she was a Denver assistant city attorney for two years and a deputy district attorney in the 20th Judicial District. The Colorado Judicial Institute and the Colorado Women's Bar Association have given her awards for judicial excellence. She earned her undergraduate degree from Lenoir-Rhyne University and her law degree from the University of Denver. She serves on the court's committees for human resources and employee engagement and for community service and engagement.

Efficiency and Decorum in Her Courtroom02

The Denver County Court Commission on Judicial Performance voted 5 to 0 that she meets performance standards. The commission writes that Judge Fay "is a model of efficiency and has demonstrated the ability to clear inundated dockets and deliver justice in a timely manner."

The commission adds that she "manages her docket in a way that ensures that all parties, including pro se litigants, have equal access to the court." It says she pairs warmth with formality on the bench, knows the law and comes prepared, and as a senior judge encourages collegiality among the court's judges.

Career03
January 2015
Appointed to the Denver County Court
Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation, 2026 evaluation
Commission evaluation04
On temperament

“She balances warmth and kindness with a formality and professionalism that establishes decorum in the courtroom.”

On respect

“She shows respect for everyone in the courtroom, including litigants, attorneys, witnesses, jurors and the general public.”

On legal knowledge

“She has an expert knowledge of the law and is organized and well prepared.”

On service to the profession

“When asked, she provides feedback to guide new attorneys in their practice.”

On leadership

“She is responsive, approachable and well respected as a leader and colleague.”

Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation, 2026 evaluation
The figures05
Commission vote
5 meet · 0 do not meet
Attorneys surveyed
Not published: “Insufficient responses to publish 2026 Survey Report”
Non-attorneys surveyed
Not published: “Insufficient responses to publish 2026 Survey Report”
Last retention election
2022: 79.53 percent yes · 154,209 yes · 39,683 no
Sources06

The 2026 election is over. Requests for personalized guides closed on November 3, 2026. The full guide remains available to read.

Read the full guide