The 2026 election is over (November 3). Official results are on the Colorado Secretary of State’s website.
Kim MonsonKim Monson · Colorado Voter's Guide 2026
CH
Retention question

Craig Peter Henderson

The Twenty-First Judicial District Judicial Performance Commission voted 8 to 0 that Judge Henderson, a former Mesa County prosecutor and Mesa County Court judge, meets performance standards.

Court
Twenty-First Judicial District - District Court
On the ballot in
Mesa County
Term
6 years
Judicial appointment
2024
Appointed by Gov. Jared Polis, 2024
Appointing governor's party: Democrat
The commission's findingMeets Performance Standardsby a vote of 8 to 0
A yes vote means

Judge Henderson stays on the Twenty-First Judicial District Court for a new six-year term.

A no vote means

Judge Henderson leaves the Twenty-First Judicial District Court at the end of his current term.

Mesa County Prosecutor and Judge01

Craig Peter Henderson was appointed to the Twenty-First Judicial District Court by Governor Jared Polis in 2024. He had been appointed to the Mesa County Court in 2006, and voters retained him on that court in 2020 with 74.3 percent of the votes cast on the question: 56,260 yes and 19,464 no.

He grew up on the eastern plains of Colorado and graduated from McPherson College and the Washburn University law school, both in Kansas. As a lawyer he worked mostly as a prosecutor, with a small amount of private practice, and in 2002 he moved to Mesa County to prosecute for the Mesa County District Attorney's Office.

Temperament, Communication and Case Handling02

One commissioner was absent for the 8 to 0 vote, and one seat was vacant. The commission reports that its 20 survey respondents unanimously agreed that he was meeting performance standards.

The commission writes that he "has made a smooth transition from being a county court judge to a district court judge" and "cares about the people in his courtroom as people, not just cases he needs to get through." After working throughout his career to improve his judicial temperament, he "now receives high marks in this area." His case handling has improved, but he "has received mixed reviews on issuing timely orders and managing his courtroom schedule." He "has generally been complimented for his legal knowledge" and has said he wants more training in domestic relations, dependency and neglect, and some civil matters. The commission calls him "a credit to the bench."

Career03
2002
Moved to Mesa County and joined the Mesa County District Attorney's Office as a prosecutor
2006
Appointed to the Mesa County Court
2024
Appointed to the Twenty-First Judicial District Court by Governor Jared Polis
Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation, 2026 evaluation
Commission evaluation04
On integrity and communication

“Judge Henderson demonstrates high levels of integrity and good communications skills.”

On explaining proceedings

“He takes the time to ensure parties understand what is happening in the courtroom.”

On criminal cases

“In criminal cases, he speaks to the defendants to ensure they understand the seriousness of their misconduct while also encouraging them to do better.”

On case management

“Judge Henderson has recognized his need to continue improving his docketing and calendar management.”

Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation, 2026 evaluation
The figures05
Commission vote
8 meet · 0 do not meet · 1 absent · 1 vacant
Attorneys surveyed
8 responses · 100% meets standards · 0% does not
Non-attorneys surveyed
13 responses · 100% meets standards · 0% does not
Last retention election
2020: 74.3 percent yes · 56,260 yes · 19,464 no
Sources06

The 2026 election is over. Requests for personalized guides closed on November 3, 2026. The full guide remains available to read.

Read the full guide