Tayler M. Thomas was appointed to the Tenth Judicial District Court in May 2023 and presides over a domestic relations and civil docket. Before becoming a judge she worked for six years in the 10th Judicial District public defender's office. A Pueblo native, she earned her law degree from Creighton University School of Law in Omaha, Nebraska, and her bachelor's degree from Colorado State University-Pueblo.

Tayler M. Thomas
Appointed to the Tenth Judicial District Court in May 2023. The Tenth Judicial District Commission voted 7 to 3 that she meets performance standards.
Judge Thomas stays on the Tenth Judicial District Court for a new six-year term.
Judge Thomas leaves the Tenth Judicial District Court at the end of her current term.
The Tenth Judicial District Commission voted 7 to 3 that she meets performance standards.
The commission writes that "Judge Thomas is well-organized, prompt in her rulings, and is proactive in ensuring her docket runs smoothly." It reports that she seeks advice from a senior judge and employs a research attorney as she works on "better formulating her court orders that integrate the law and facts". The commission writes: "Although improving, the Commission finds Judge Thomas continues to lack impartiality. Judge Thomas, at times, favors one litigant over another, based, in part, by the litigants’ attorneys." It adds: "The Commission is confident Judge Thomas will continue to work on this bias."
The commission notes that she volunteers at her daughter's school and has mentored a middle school student, and writes that it "would like to see Judge Thomas become more involved in community service activities in Pueblo".
“Judge Thomas takes advantage of learning opportunities, including trainings offered by the judicial branch and the Colorado Bar Association.”
- 2026 evaluation of Judge Tayler M. Thomas (Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation)
- 2026 Retention Survey Report (Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation)
- 2025 Interim Survey Report (Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation)
- Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation, 2026 evaluation